Mutual funds are one of the most popular investment options for long-term wealth creation. If you are a first-time investor or someone who wants to build a big corpus, two of the most common investment methods are SIPs and lump sum investments.
Both approaches benefit from the power of compounding, but they are very different in investment style, risk exposure, and time to reach a financial goal. A common question among investors is whether investing Rs 5,000 every month through an SIP can outperform a one-time investment of Rs 1 lakh in reaching a target corpus.
Here we compare based on an annual return of 12%.
What is a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP)?
A Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) allows investors to invest a fixed amount at regular intervals (typically every month). SIPs encourage disciplined investment and reduce the need to time the market. The value in rupees is spread over time, so investors benefit from rupee cost averaging, which would help curb market volatility.
SIPs are also quite accessible to those who can start with a small amount, so SIPs are attractive to salaried people and those who want to start building wealth slowly.
What is a lump-sum investment?
A lump sum investment is a large amount of money invested in a mutual fund for a single transaction. Many investors are given bonuses, inheritances, or assets sold from a property or other asset, and/or a large amount of money in a mutual fund in the process.
Since the entire amount is invested at once, returns will depend heavily on market conditions at the time of investment. If taken during a market downturn, a lump sum investment may yield an attractive long-term return. However, investing just before a market correction can temporarily lower portfolio value.
Rs 5,000 monthly SIP vs Rs 1 Lakh Lump Sum
Assuming a 12% annual return, a Rs 5,000 monthly SIP can accumulate a corpus of nearly Rs 20 lakh in approximately 13 to 14 years.
During this period:
- Monthly SIP: Rs 5,000
- Total investment: About Rs 8 lakh.
- Estimated Corpus: Around Rs 20 lakh.
- Time required: 13-14 years
A significant portion of the final corpus comes from compound growth, where the returns over time also start earning returns.
In comparison, a one-time lump sum investment of Rs 1 lakh, assuming the same annual return of 12%, may take around 26 years to grow to around Rs 20 lakh.
One-Time Investment: Rs 1 lakh. Estimated Corpus: Around Rs 20 lakh. Time Required: About 26 years
Though the lump sum investment does not require any further investments, it depends only on the long-term compounding of the initial amount. On the other hand, the SIP will benefit from continuous investment alongside compounding to get the money to the end much sooner.
What is better?
The comparison shows that a Rs 5,000 monthly SIP reaches the Rs 20 lakh target almost twice as fast as a one-time investment of Rs 1 lakh under the assumed rate of return.
However, that does not necessarily mean SIPs are always better. The right choice depends on an investor’s financial situation.
A SIP is well-suited for a regular monthly income to invest in a disciplined way and to avoid market swings.
And when market valuations are favourable, a lump sum investment may be appropriate for investors who already have a substantial amount available and can remain invested for the long term.
Most experienced investors, too, will take advantage of both strategies and invest windfall gains in a lump sum and continue the regular SIP investments for the long term to increase wealth creation.
Final Takeaway
SIPs and lump sums are both effective tools for building wealth over time. So much of staying invested, compounding works, and planning an investment strategy that fits your financial goals and risk tolerance.
Though in this case we assume a constant return of 12% per annum, mutual fund returns are market-based and will vary with the market performance. Investors should analyze their financial objectives, investment horizon, and risk appetite before making investment decisions.
The above calculations are for illustrative purposes only. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks, and returns are not guaranteed. Investors need to read all scheme-related documents carefully before investing.
Comments
Please to leave a comment on this article.